Abstract
High-sensitivity cardiac troponin (hs-cTn) assays have increased detection of myocardial injury in hospitalized patients, but clinical practice has not fully adapted to the distinction between biomarker positivity and myocardial infarction (MI). In medically complex inpatients, troponin elevation commonly reflects myocardial injury or type 2 MI rather than acute coronary thrombosis. As a result, reflexive labeling as MI can trigger antithrombotic therapy, low-yield invasive testing, and durable diagnostic labels that shape downstream care.
This narrative review synthesizes contemporary consensus definitions, guideline statements, and peer-reviewed clinical studies relevant to hs-cTn interpretation in hospitalized and critically ill adults. Emphasis is placed on classification, inpatient diagnostic pitfalls, management patterns, and downstream consequences of misclassification, including common inpatient contexts such as sepsis, perioperative illness, tachyarrhythmias, and chronic kidney disease.
Across inpatient cohorts, hs-cTn elevation is frequent, whereas adjudicated type 1 MI represents a minority of abnormal results. Mechanisms of troponin release extend beyond plaque rupture and include inflammatory signaling, membrane permeability changes, apoptosis, and mechanical stretch in overlapping physiologic stressors. Observational studies suggest that diagnostic labeling influences care trajectories, with higher rates of coronary angiography and secondary prevention therapy without clear long-term mortality benefit. In addition, cognitive heuristics, indiscriminate testing, and incomplete clinical context contribute to diagnostic momentum.
Accordingly, hs-cTn elevation should be interpreted using a probability-driven, mechanism-based framework that requires ischemic corroboration to diagnose MI, uses serial change to determine acuity rather than mechanism, prioritizes identification and treatment of reversible stressors, and escalates to imaging or invasive evaluation selectively when ischemic suspicion remains high.
Recommended Citation
Zafar Ahmed, Syed Sami N; Nazir, Fahd J.; Barak, Zahed; and Ali, Babar
(2026)
"When Troponin is Positive but the Diagnosis Is Not: Diagnostic Pitfalls and a Mechanism-Based Approach in Hospitalized Patients,"
Journal of Community Hospital Internal Medicine Perspectives: Vol. 16:
Iss.
6, Article 10.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55729/2000-9666.1665
Available at:
https://scholarlycommons.gbmc.org/jchimp/vol16/iss6/10
DOI
10.55729/2000-9666.1665
